Small Business Saturday: win the second visit

A smiling florist hands a paper bag of flowers to a happy customer across the counter of a small flower shop

In the U.S., Small Business Saturday falls on November 28 this year, the Saturday after Thanksgiving. New research from American Express, released on November 12, says 88% of U.S. consumers agree they are likely to shop at small businesses this holiday season. The same 2026 Shop Small Impact Study shows how people choose where to go: recommendations from friends and family come first (65%), then customer reviews (45%), then social media posts (39%).

Read that order again. The thing that brings most new customers to a small business is what other customers say about it. So the most valuable part of Small Business Saturday isn’t the sale on the day. It’s what the new person does after they leave: come back, leave a review, tell a friend. That part happens after the sale, and it rarely happens by itself.

Here’s a simple plan to turn Saturday’s new faces into regulars who bring the next customer.

Before Saturday: make it easy to stay in touch

Most first-time visitors walk out and you never hear from them again. Not because they didn’t like you, but because you have no way to reach them. Fix that before the weekend:

  • Ask, don’t grab. At checkout, ask: “Can I send you a quick thank-you and let you know when something new comes in?” Write down the name and the phone number or email only if they say yes.
  • Note what they bought or asked about. One word is enough: “candles”, “kids’ books”, “gift for mom”. It makes your next message personal.
  • Keep it in one place. A notebook, a spreadsheet or labels in your WhatsApp Business app. Not five phones and a pile of receipts.

Within two days: a short thank-you

Send one message, in your own words, during business hours. For example: “Hi Sarah, thanks for stopping by on Saturday! I hope your sister loves the candle. If you need anything else, just reply here.” No discount, no link, no pressure. You’re starting a conversation, not running a promotion.

If they reply, answer quickly. A reply that waits until next week feels like nobody’s there. We wrote about this in how fast you should reply to a lead.

About a week later: ask for the review

The best time to ask for a review is when the customer has had time to enjoy what they bought, not while they’re still standing in line. About a week later, send one short message with the direct link to your Google Business Profile review page: “If you enjoyed your visit, a short review on Google would help other people find us. Here’s the link.”

Two rules make this work. Ask everyone the same way, not only the customers you think will be kind. And reply to every review, the good ones and the critical ones, calmly and by name. People who are deciding whether to visit read your replies too.

Make the referral easy, not awkward

You don’t need a complicated referral program. You need one clear sentence at the right moment, usually when a customer thanks you or comes back a second time: “If you know someone who’d like this, feel free to send them my number. Tell them you sent them, and I’ll take good care of them.”

When a new person arrives and mentions a name, write down who referred them, and thank that customer. A personal message is often enough. That’s how one good visit turns into the next customer.

Not a shop? The same steps work

The study looked at shops, restaurants and personal services, but the idea works for any business that sells by talking to people. A clinic can thank a new patient after the first visit. A studio or gym can follow up after the trial class. A school can thank the family that came to the open day. First the thank-you, then the review, then the referral.

Do this this week

  1. Before Saturday, write your thank-you message and your review request, and save both as quick replies in your phone.
  2. At checkout, ask every new customer if you can send a thank-you, and write down who said yes and what they were looking for.
  3. On Monday or Tuesday, send the thank-you. Put a note in your calendar for the review request about a week later.

Where Conquia fits

In Conquia, this is the after the sale block, through customer success: a welcome for every new customer, review requests at the right moment and referral campaigns. The person who was referred enters at the start of the funnel, before the sale, with the referral recorded as the source, so you can see how many customers came from referrals. The messages go out through the campaign engine with the same safeguards: at most two a week per person, only during business hours, and anyone who opts out never hears from you again. The AI can draft the messages and shows why it suggested each one, but nothing goes out until you approve it.

From first click to loyal customer.

Conquia isn’t on sale to the public yet. We’re opening it step by step, starting with a group of selected businesses. Join the waitlist and be first to know when it’s your turn.

Join the waitlist

Conquia